Retailers Perplexed :Branded Products Vs. Private Label

Guru marketers in the corner offices of major retailers continue to throw darts when it comes to merchandising private label vs. branded products.

Maybe everyone should take a hint from today's WSJ profile of Cott Corp--the private label soda manufacturer whose shares are falling flat--much in part because Wal-Mart has determined that its customers are more interested in branded products vs. the Sam's label.

We all know that manufacturers have been hammered over the past several years as retailers seek to introduce lower cost, higher margin goods. Private labeling necessarily accomplishes that goal, especially when faced with declining revenue from slotting fees that are part and parcel to many chain store business models.

But a funny thing seems to be happening on the way to the checkout counter--other than the most rudimentary staple items (i.e. napkins, nails, or the most highly commoditized), consumers still cherish a branded product--and the lower priced "house brands" within the food, beverage, personal care categories are simply not appealing, even to the most price sensitive shoppers.